Where does Strawbale Building Work?
Dr. Owen Geiger, Ph.D.( in Social and Economic Development,) is the former Director of Builders Without Borders and current member of the BWB Steering Committee. Dr. Geiger is Founder and Director of the Geiger Research Institute of Sustainable Building (www.grisb.org). He is an author, engineer and licensed contractor specializing in strawbale construction and other types of sustainable building. He co-authored the Builders Without Borders Straw-Bale Construction Guides and contributed to Building Without Borders: Sustainable Construction for the Global Village. Dr. Geiger has consulted on numerous international housing projects, worked closely with Habitat for Humanity for seven years and mentored housing officials with the United Nations Institute of Training and Research. He is also a correspondent for The Last Straw Journal. Dr. Geiger's Global Straw-Bale Construction Certification Program provides high quality strawbale training via a unique program that combines hands-on experiences with research and assignments; this is a distance learning program for those within reach of the internet and with an adequate knowledge of English. See www.grisb.org for more information.
Q: I am investigating the feasibility of bringing a straw bale building workshop to my city, Thunder Bay Ontario Canada. I'd like to do it at some point this summer. I haven't yet read anything that would make me think that straw bale construction isn't suitable for our climate (long cold winters)...but please correct me if I'm wrong!
A: Yes, you can build straw bale structures in Ontario. Straw bale buildings have been built in Oregon,Washington and all across Canada, including Nova Scotia, all of which receive high rainfall. As with any type of building - wood frame, strawbale, etc., the main thing you need to do in rainy climates is protect the walls from moisture damage. This can be accomplished by building wide roof overhangs, raising the bale walls a safe distance above grade and sloping the site away from the building. Another key point is do not use moisture barriers in the walls. You want to allow any moisture that may get into the walls to escape.
Here are some recommended resources:
Q: I am currently in Gainesville, Florida for a short visit. I live in California and have a lot in the Sierra foothills south of Yosemite. My plan is to build a strawbale home on the lot. Do you know of any strawbale structures in Northern Florida, and in particular, the Gainesville area?
A: Check the International Straw Bale Registry: sbregistry.greenbuilder.com . Most strawbale homes are not listed, but it's worth a try. A far better resource is the Fall Resource issue of The Last Straw that lists architects, builders, etc. by state and country: www.thelaststraw.org . Also note, that Florida is far from the ideal climate for strawbale, and therefore has very few houses. Be sure to visit with builders in Colorado, etc. on your way to Yosemite and I guarantee you will be amazed.
Q: I live in northwest Florida and plan on building a home in the next 1-1/2 years. It will be in a wooded area on the family farm. My brother grows/sells hay. Is a straw-insulated house feasible in this humid environment where we spend most of our electricity on air-conditioning rather than heating? I'm looking to build a small home with porches, an open floor plan with a basement. If a straw-insulated home is not feasible because of the humidity, which "green" product would be?
A: Strawbale is ideally suited to dry hot climates, cold climates and temperate climates with hot/cold seasonal swings. People have built strawbale buildings in Florida and other hot/humid climates, but I think the benefits will be somewhat less. Wide wrap-around porches, trees for shade, capturing breezes, natural ventilation, good design to guard against roof leaks, and other factors are important considerations. And just to be clear (you said your brother grows hay), straw is different than hay. Be sure to use straw made from the stems of cereal grains.
Q: How well do straw bale houses do in the hot California Deserts? Also how many years do they typically last under normal conditions and under severe conditions? Are they a low maintenance house?
A: SB houses have lasted for 100 years in the windy, cold climate of western Nebraska. Keep in mind those old houses were poorly built. Houses built to modern standards would be much more durable, and they would last even longer in the desert due to the lack of moisture. The modern strawbale movement is centered in New Mexico, Arizona, SW Colorado, and southern California -- the desert southwest -- with thousands of houses now completed. They can last as long as any other house if they're maintained.
Q: I'm doing some research on this method and was wondering if there is a concise list or site to view current codes by state. I noticed that straw bale structures are not in just one area of the country, which brought up the issue of resistance to wind, rain, snow and ice - in other words, how these structures resist the elements.
Q: I just started to research hay-bail homes and I wanted to know what you thought of them in the hot Florida weather? Will the humidity cause us a problem? Also if you could recommend and info source that you like about hay bail homes.
A: (Kelly) I would think that a well-designed and constructed strawbale home in Florida would do fine. Make sure that it has a good foundation, well off the ground, and good eaves over the walls, to keep most of the moisture off of them. Then make sure that walls are breathable, so that if any moisture that does get in, it can get back out. Straw is very good insulation so it should help keep the home cool, especially if there is some thermal mass inside to help stabilize temperatures.
As for information, there are several books, periodicals, and links listed on this page that are quite informative. I have the Steen's original book on strawbale, and it is excellent, but I know that many of the others are also good.
Q: I'm interested in using local materials (rock from local quarries and/or straw bales) to build a home myself. I live in west-central Minnesota. Is it possible/feasible to build such a home in this climate/geographic area?
A: (Jeff Ruppert) Absolutely! Rock and straw bales go together very well. I would recommend a vernacular style house, meaning a one or two story house with large overhangs, walls made of bales with a two to 3 foot rock wainscot. The foundation can incorporate the rock if you want. Rock from the quarries can also be used in any interior thermal mass, such as fireplace mantels, or as the fireplaces themselves. Interior walls or floors are a couple other places for their use. Sounds like a fun project!
Q: Our home is built next to a hill that's covered in rubble leftover from blasting done to get the house built (not the site we would have chosen, had we built it here!). The hill continues to creep toward the house, not to mention it's pretty ugly. We call it our moonscape. Anyway, we're considering inexpensive ideas for a retaining wall and thought strawbales may be good. My husband is concerned about how much load such a wall could hold back, as well as concerned about the moisture that may seep under a wall, since the hill is very steep. Do you have any ideas on this, and/or can you recommend other sources?
A: (Kelly) I would advise you not to use strawbales to create a retaining wall...you would be asking for trouble down the road, since it would be nearly impossible to keep moisture from migrating into the wall and the straw eventually decomposing. I would suggest using earthbags with the soil at your site; this would be very inexpensive and rot-free. You might look at this page for some ideas.
I have a bit of a japanese-style fetish when it comes to my dream home - a courtyard within the home and the living quarters to the outside perimeter. Please tell me, kind sir, does my dream home include an economically and environmentally efficient straw-bale premise?
C: A veranda-like covered walk will be utilized to accent the surround of the inner building. Great suggestion!! What really excites me is the R-60 insulation value - once the home is 66 degrees, it stays 66 degrees!!
Q: I am considering buying land in central or western North Carolina. Is it feasible to build a straw bale house in such a wet hurricane prone climate? Who would be able to help me build this house? Are there general contractors that do this and where would I go to find building codes for this construction?
Hurricanes: Almost any structure, including strawbale buildings, can be designed for hurricane resistance. Consult a local engineer who specializes in this. Note: the wide roof overhangs and wrap-around porches mentioned above are more prone to hurricane damage. So look at the overall design and weigh all the factors.
Q: I own some land on the coast in Jalisco Mex. I was thinking about building a strawbale home. My friends there laugh at me because of the amount of termites and other insects in the area. I have access to rice straw, clay and sand. What do you believe would be my best options for materials to keep my home cool. I live in a micro-climate where we do not get much rain and if we do it will be from a hurricane.
A: Strawbale is certainly one option. Straw bale homes have been built in climates far worse than what you've described. (Ignore the critics -- it's common to get skeptical comments any time you do something new or different.) From what the literature says, termites are not attracted to straw bales. There's no nutrition. Still, you need to be very careful they don't try to nest in the walls. Another issue is bale quality. Can you get high quality, compact bales?
Q: I am interested in building a straw bale house in France. I understand that they have survived well in cold climates but are these climates in america anything like the climate in France. Do you think a straw bale house will survive in France? and if so how long and will it need any special attention?
Q: Here in France Autumn is just around the corner and it is going to get colder; is that a problem or can a straw house be built at any time of year? I am also a beginner when it comes to building, in fact this will be my first build ever. Do you think you could recommend a book with a lot of useful information for beginners, written in a basic language? and another book to follow the first one, to make a collection that will help me build a really great building? I need a lot of diagrams and detailed step by step processes as I am dyslexic and would find it much easier to follow. I can read and write OK but complicated language, and technical terms will only confuse me if I cannot understand what is meant.
A: The best book for beginners is Build it With Bales, by Matts Myhrman. It's loaded with simplified drawings and how-to information. However, some of the material is outdated. Examples: Using bales to insulate under the floor is NOT recommended, and pounding rebar through the bales is no longer done.
Q: How do you build in tropical places, sustainable straw bale?
Q: I was wondering if you know of any straw bale homes in Pennsylvania, and if it is possible. It seems likely considering the climates of all the other states using strawbales.
A: Buy the Fall Resource issue of The Last Straw to locate designers, builders and architects in your area. Most will be happy to show you their projects. And yes, there are strawbale projects in Pennsylvania.
Q: I'm looking for a greener way to build our new head house/office/potting shed for a nursery business. I am considering strawbale; probably non-load bearing due to the alternative nature and lack of experience of the inspectors in the area. There would be a long overhang as part of the design but the greenhouse must be physically attached due to shipping requirements (necessary business requirement). The attachment would be an 8' wide vestibule with somewhat open swing doors, but could be made fairly tight. However, they'd be swinging all day allowing very moist air into the structure. Is this untenable for strawbale? Should I consider something like papercrete or is there a suitable solution to protect the interior walls from moisture?
A: Straw-bale building is very durable, although every building system has its limits. Using bales in an extreme moist environment is not the best choice when alternatives are available. My preference for wet environments is earthbag building. The polypropylene bags are unaffected by moisture and should last 100 years or longer if kept out of sunlight.
Q: Is strawbale or straw/clay construction practical for the San Antonio, Texas environment? We are wanting to build a home using sustainable architecture and like the look of straw bale and straw/clay structures, but are uncertain about how well it would work with the humidity level here in San Antonio.
A: Yes, straw-bale construction and straw/clay are both fine for Texas. In fact, Texas is a 'hot bed' of strawbale building (as well as other types of natural building). It's always important to become informed and use good building design, even more so in rainy and humid environments. Get a subscription to The Last Straw Journal. You'll end up with a better house and recoup your subscription cost many times over.
Q: I'm a B. Arch final year student conducting my thesis on sustainable housing in Pakistan. I'm thinking of using straw-bale as material for construction of housing units as they are locally available, reusable, natural and inexpensive. Plus it can deal well in Pakistan's climatic conditions. All I need to know is that how many stories could be erected using strawbale as construction material and how much load can this material withstand. Another thing I want to ask is how can we protect it from getting damp and what kind of plaster should be used? lime or cement? I don't have any idea as to how the foundations of such house would be made.
I know some people working with strawbale housing in Pakistan and it is working quite well: www.paksbab.org. They should be able to answer detailed questions. Strawbale testing results are here: www.ecobuildnetwork.org/strawbale.htm. Extensive testing has paved the way for strawbale construction to be approved by the building codes. If properly designed, SB houses are approved even in earthquake zones in California where the codes are very strict (which means you can build safe houses for anywhere in the world if designed correctly).
Q: Is it possible to build a straw / adobe home in Nebraska? Or would our weather prevent this?
Strawbale houses originated in western Nebraska, in the Sandhills region a little over 100 years ago. Some houses are still standing and being lived in. Straw bale houses made sense then and they still make sense today, especially in cold climates like Nebraska. (I lived in Lincoln about 20 years and work for The Last Straw Journal, which is in Lincoln.)
A: I would use all earthbags, or maybe add some bales or cordwood on non-bermed walls. Earthbags are ideal for what you're doing. Our websites cover every aspect of earthbag building: www.EarthbagBuilding.com Maybe your non-bermed walls are primarily window walls that will get some driving rain, in which case bales and cordwood wouldn't be the best choice. You could build 2x6 frames for these wall with possibly stone or recycled brick facing on lower areas.
Q: I have moved to Puglia, which has high moisture in Winter. Would the climate be suitable for a straw baled house?
A: Strawbale is okay in Puglia. Just make sure you raise the bales high enough off the ground and use wide roof overhangs.
Q: I wonder if its possible (or a good idea) to build a zero energy strawbale house in the south of Sweden (fairly warm summers and long wet/cold winters) The size of the house will need to be about 2400 sq ft.
A: Strawbale seems to be the preferred natural building technique in Europe -- that and hempcrete, timberframe and wood/chip clay. All should work fine. The Last Straw Journal has links to all the international groups, including European natural builders. They sell back issues. Buy their annual Resource issue.
Q: We are planning on moving to northern Missouri and building a timber frame strawbale home. There are a number of people who have built strawbale homes in the area who are reporting that black mold is a issue due to the humid climate. We understand that ventilation and protection from the rain are extremely important. Our question is regarding whether strawbale is appropriate for such a humid climate (though it is quite cold in winter), and if so, what are the specific ventilation techniques recommended.
A: It isn't worth the risk in my opinion. Ten years ago when there were far fewer homes to examine, it seemed okay. More feedback is coming in and lots of strawbale houses are molding in climates like yours. I heard that every strawbale house in at least one area of Pennsylvania was moldy. I would use materials that don't mold and then you never have to worry. This includes not using sheetrock, carpet, particle board, central heating ductwork, etc. Do the research and simply don't use products that will mold.
Q: I'm from Eastern Kentucky. I have been interested in straw bale homes, and would like to know your opinion about building such a home in my region, or should I try another resource. We don't have much income here in Appalachia and coal is not the answer.
A: (Kelly) There have been many successful strawbale homes built in your region, so this should be a viable option for you. As in any area, it is important for the home to be well designed and built, allowing plenty of foundation above the ground, a good roof with large eaves, and a substantial (and breathable) plaster over the bales.